I think that we once asked for your favourite episode or series? But your favs may have changed and, as pointed out by many, it is difficult to pick one fav so I thought I would try a different approach in asking for your top 5 - indicating, if you like, your order of preference; if you don't have 5 then just give those you do like!!
Just noticed this thread. Nice to see I have a firm grasp of what is going on around me, eh?
My top 2 are Series 1, Episodes 1 and 2. Just love them. Next comes the American Joe MacDonald episode. (2:8) Then the one with the duel in it with Morag MacDonald's husband (4:7, which also includes Irene getting pregnant and Duncan's lucky wishing stone). And finally, 3:10 & 11, which I count as one long episode.
But really, I would need a top 10 list, since I also love the whisky barrel episode, and Stella's strict cost cutting episode, and the Marie Helene episode, and the one where Hector gets to lecture about whisky (selling Molly's paintings), and the Edith Rankin episode, and....well, you get the idea. ;D